Connect with us

Health

We Are Pushing Nature to the Edge—But Solutions Are Within Reach: Global Conversations on Sustainable Health

Published

on

By Davidson Ndyabahika and Johanna Blomgren

We’ve all done it—tossed leftovers, ignored wilted greens, or shrugged at a half-eaten meal. Food waste is a quiet guilt we all share, a reflex in a world of abundance and scarcity. But what if this small act connects to a larger global issue? On February 26, 2025, experts from Uganda, Sweden, and beyond gathered in a virtual seminar, asking, “How can we nourish ourselves without harming the planet?” Hosted by the Centre of Excellence for Sustainable Health (CESH), the discussion revealed a harsh truth—our food habits are draining the Earth.

The discussion on sustainable food systems marked the beginning of the annual four-part global conversation on sustainable health, organized through a collaboration between Sweden’s Karolinska Institutet and Uganda’s Makerere University under the auspices of CESH.

In Kampala, the paradox is stark. Every day, 750 tons of food waste fill the city’s landfills, enough to feed thousands. Rotten mangoes spill from crates in Nakasero Market, and half-eaten Rolex wraps pile behind street stalls. Uganda’s Food Rights Alliance shows 37.8% of this waste comes from plates and markets. Across East Africa, organic waste, like spoiled vegetables and discarded tubers, makes up 79% of urban trash—a grim reflection of broken systems. Beyond this is a city stuck with piles and piles of organic trash, which has previously been fatal with a slide in one of Kampala’s major landfills. Meanwhile, 26% of Uganda’s children remain stunted.

At the heart of this week’s global conversation was the WWF’s Living Planet Report 2024, a sobering revelation of a 73% decline in global wildlife populations since 1970. Freshwater ecosystems have hemorrhaged 85% of biodiversity, Latin America’s species richness has plummeted by 95%, and Africa—home to smallholder farmers who feed millions—has lost 76%. “Nature is disappearing at an alarming rate,” warned Harold Turinawe, WWF Uganda’s Forest Markets Transformation Manager, his voice weighted with urgency.

“We are pushing Earth’s systems to irreversible tipping points, and despite the increase in food production and land use and the destruction of habitats, the world is still hungry; we have over 735 million people going to bed hungry every other night. The contradiction is striking,” Turinawe added.

Mr. Harold Turinawe, Forest Markets Transformation Manager, World Wide Fund for Nature, Uganda Country Office. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH), Kampala Uganda, East Africa-Karolinska Institutet, Sweden, Centre of Excellence for Sustainable Health (CESH)-Global Conversations on Sustainable Health.

The report highlights the Amazon’s lush canopies that are felled for cattle ranches. The interplay of man’s unsustainable utilization of Mother Nature, leading to the food paradox, feast, famine, and ecological ruin, underscores the urgency of addressing global goals in a coordinated manner.

The report’s indictment of industrial food systems is clear: agriculture claims 40% of habitable land, 70% of freshwater, and drives 25% of greenhouse emissions. Yet, 735 million people still starve nightly. “Our obsession with monocultures and processed foods isn’t just destroying habitats—it’s failing humanity,” said Dr. Rawlance Ndejjo, the seminar’s moderator and a public health lecturer at Makerere University.

Florence Tushemerirwe, a Ugandan public health nutrition expert based at Makerere University’s School of Public Health, pointed out the irony: 26% of children are stunted, while obesity rises among adults in Uganda. “We grow nutrient-rich crops but export them, leaving people dependent on cheap, processed imports. In fact, many people do not appreciate their nutrient value,” she said. Uganda’s iodine-depleted soils now rely on fortified foods—a temporary fix for a growing crisis.

Ms. Florence Tushemerirwe, Public Health Nutritionist and Research Associate. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH), Kampala Uganda, East Africa-Karolinska Institutet, Sweden, Centre of Excellence for Sustainable Health (CESH)-Global Conversations on Sustainable Health.

All through the seminar, the message was clear: we are wasting abundance while ecosystems crumble and people go hungry. “Our salt is iodized because our soils no longer provide it. Biodiversity loss isn’t abstract—it’s stealing nutrients from our plates. But if we don’t maintain our nature’s health, or our environmental health, or our natural resources health, it means that whatever food we grow, we actually do not carry the nutrients we need to maintain a diverse diet,” said Tushemerirwe.

The panel dissected global food trade’s role. WWF’s Turinawe lamented, “90% of deforestation is for agriculture. In Uganda, the once-vibrant wetland ecosystems of Lwera at the shores of Lake Victoria now face severe degradation due to large-scale rice growers; in the Amazon, its cattle ranches.”

Dr. Rachel Marie Mazac of Stockholm Resilience Centre stressed Europe’s complicity: “Sweden’s ‘virtual biodiversity loss’—importing deforestation via beef and soy—shows how our diets export destruction.”

“From a Swedish perspective, we are highly dependent on imports, particularly raw materials, which contribute significantly to biodiversity loss in other regions. It’s difficult to pinpoint the exact impact, especially with biodiversity, but there’s a concept of “virtual impact,” says Dr. Mazac.

Dr. Rachel Mazac, Postdoctoral Researcher, Stockholm Resilience Centre, Stockholm University. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH), Kampala Uganda, East Africa-Karolinska Institutet, Sweden, Centre of Excellence for Sustainable Health (CESH)-Global Conversations on Sustainable Health.

Food consumed in Sweden, though produced elsewhere, contributes to biodiversity loss in those areas. The issue links to trade, food production, and distribution. It’s not just about production or waste but also equitable distribution.

Dr. Ndejjo added starkly, “You could be eating a burger from a cow grazed on razed Amazon forest. Guilt isn’t enough—we need systemic change.”

Amid the grim statistics, the panelists outlined a roadmap for redemption: nature-positive agriculture, subsidy policy reform, improved localized diets, global accountability, and honest discussions on the GMO dilemma.

Turinawe emphasized the need for agroecology in extension services—integrating trees, crops, and livestock to rebuild soil health and biodiversity. He stressed while critiquing Uganda’s Parish Development Extension Model for prioritizing enterprises for profit over sustainability. “We are saying get one million to a farmer. What are they producing? They are engaging in commodities that are predetermined. Nobody’s talking about Mother Nature. Who takes care of the soil? Who takes care of the water needs? Who takes care of the diversification we are talking about? But diversification in the diet begins with diversification on the farm. So my first issue is strengthening the agricultural extension services,” says Turinawe.

Adding that things like soil health management, land tenure system farmer-to-farmer network for peer learning, and fair farmer subsidies should be key to planning and agricultural extension.

“In Uganda, where I come from, and currently in Kampala, if you head north towards Zirobwe in Luweero District, you’ll find people we call Bibanja owners—essentially squatters who don’t own the land they occupy. These individuals cannot engage in sustainable agriculture as we’re discussing; their focus is survival. What we need are programs that give farmers secure land rights, which can motivate them to invest in soil health and environmental conservation—investments that take time. Improving soil is not a short-term effort; it requires long-term actions like planting trees, integrating practices, and using farmyard manure. None of this is realistic for someone who fears being displaced tomorrow. We need to approach this challenge collectively.”

Subsidies must reward sustainable practices, not industrial giants.

“Why not tax breaks for farmers using organic manure?” Turinawe challenged. “I would love to hear that a farmer that is engaged in sustainable cocoa production and coffee production gets a tax holiday rather than having a blanket of investors getting a holiday. Put subsidies and investment incentives in the right direction. We shall spur production, and of course, this will also bring in corporate partnerships, and we can make our supply chains safer, better, more green, and more sustainable,” Turinawe added.

Dr. Mazac noted that “nature-positive production can feed the world by optimizing crops, livestock, and wild fisheries, and supporting aquaculture that works with wetlands, not against them.” For Mazac, policy is key: She is also an advocate of subsidies and taxes that benefit farmers. Those that ensure incentives that improve soil health and maintain water quality as well as tackle climate change in order to make sustainability profitable.

“We must rethink trade to avoid widening the gap between food-producing areas and markets and instead support local farmers. Subsidies and taxes should empower these communities to nourish their populations before focusing on exports. While exports generate income, they also have significant impacts. A possible solution is changing production systems, but we must also shift dietary and consumption habits, making this a collective effort, not just an individual responsibility.”

Tushemerirwe is hungry for reviving indigenous crops and regulating predatory marketing. “Awareness is power. We must teach communities to value their traditional foods over processed substitutes.”

“There is good food grown in rural areas and available in markets, but people don’t recognize its value due to lack of guidance. We need food-based data guidelines to raise awareness. The Uganda Ministry of Health has a draft for this, along with draft policies to regulate unhealthy food marketing, especially to children. Junk food is advertised everywhere: hospitals, schools, and even street billboards, with fast food chains clustered together. We must regulate this and educate people on the nutritional benefits of eating what they grow over imported alternatives,” she stated.

Dr. Ndejjo believes these draft guidelines to regulate unhealthy food marketing should be finalized into policies and urges policymakers and implementers to prioritize the urgent need for these documents.

Dr. Rawlence Ndejjo, Lecturer, Department of Disease Control and Environmental Health. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH), Kampala Uganda, East Africa-Karolinska Institutet, Sweden, Centre of Excellence for Sustainable Health (CESH)-Global Conversations on Sustainable Health.

The conversation also weighed in on the genetic engineering in agriculture for increased crop yields, popular for GMOs, a dilemma that panelists called for their democratization rather than demonizing them. While Dr. Mazac cautioned against corporate-controlled seeds, Turinawe acknowledged their potential: “If democratized, drought-resistant crops could save farms in a warming world.”

Dr. Mazac noted that while in Europe and the European Union, they are not allowed to grow or sell foods that have been genetically modified, the essence of them should not be overlooked, since they are a technology that seeks to solve the future food crisis.

 “GMOs aren’t inherently evil. Drought-resistant crops could save farms—but corporate patents trap farmers,” she said.

Turinawe added, “Our approach to GMO’s is a measure one bordering more on ethics and responsible use of GMOs; we see GMOs as a tool to promote resilience, especially since everything has changed—the food we once relied on can no longer grow in the same way. If GMOs help improve crop resilience, that’s a valuable tool. However, there are concerns that companies like Monsanto could use the GMO technology as a tool of exclusion, e.g., the fear of monopolizing future seed markets. This is where caution is needed.”

A Call for Radical Collaboration

The seminar’s resounding theme was unity: multi-sectoral collaboration is non-negotiable. From street food vendors to policymakers in the boardrooms, every actor must align. “Food systems aren’t siloed,” Dr. Mazac asserted. “They’re woven into climate, economy, and culture.”

“I think we need to sit and agree and engage quite regularly and find solutions for us to be able to produce food but sustainably,” concluded Tushemerirwe.

The Path Ahead

CESH’s global conversations on sustainable health are a microcosm of a global awakening, especially in tracking progress to meet our goals for 2030 and beyond: This seminar on food systems emphasizes the interconnectedness of food security and biodiversity. With the next UN Climate Summit (COP29) on the horizon, the panel’s message is clear—transformative change is possible, but only through courage, equity, and an unyielding reverence for nature.

To find more about this global conversation on sustainable health and more, visit CESH.health

Davidson Ndyabahika and Johanna Blomgren are the co-organisers of the global conversation on sustainable health

Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH), Kampala Uganda, East Africa-Karolinska Institutet, Sweden, Centre of Excellence for Sustainable Health (CESH)-Global Conversations on Sustainable Health.

View on MakSPH

Mak Editor

Health

Professor Nakimuli awarded at FIGO Congress for outstanding contribution to Women and Child Health

Published

on

Dr. Annettee Nakimuli, Associate Professor of Obstetrics and Gynaecology and Dean, School of Medicine, Makerere University College of Health Sciences. Kampala Uganda, East Africa.

Dr. Annettee Nakimuli, an Associate Professor of Obstetrics & Gynaecology and Dean – School of Medicine at Makerere University College of Health Sciences was awarded by the International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) for her outstanding contribution to improving the health of Women and children as a researcher and practitioner.

She received the award on the 6th Oct 2025 at the FIGO General Assembly/FIGO Congress that is ongoing in Cape Town, South Africa.

Professor Nakimuli is a leading maternal health researcher focused primarily on investigating the aetiology, treatment, prevention and long term outcomes of pregnancy complications among women in Sub-Saharan Africa. She is committed to building maternal and new-born research capacity in Africa and her aim is, with East African and International colleagues, to establish a multidisciplinary centre for African maternal and neonatal health research located at Makerere University in Uganda.

View on CHS

Zaam Ssali

Continue Reading

Health

MakSPH, TalTech Partner to Shape the Future of Digital Health in Uganda

Published

on

At the centre, MakSPH Dean, Prof. Rhoda Wanyenze and H.E. Girisch M. Nair, Honorary Consul of Estonia to Uganda with stakeholders at the project launch. September 9, 2025. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH) and Estonia’s Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) kick-off meeting for two-year collaborative project to transform health informatics education and practice in Uganda, supported by the Estonian Centre for International Development (ESTDEV), 9th September 2025, MakSPH Auditorium, Kampala Uganda, East Africa.

Kampala, UgandaMakerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH) and Estonia’s Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) have launched a two-year collaborative project to transform health informatics education and practice in Uganda, positioning the country as a regional leader in digital health. Unveiled earlier this month at MakSPH and supported by the Estonian Centre for International Development (ESTDEV), the initiative aims to build a skilled digital health workforce and accelerate Uganda’s transition to a data-driven health system, while aligning the country’s digital agenda with global best practices through partnership.

This strategic collaboration builds on the success of MakSPH’s Master of Health Informatics (MHI) programme. The MHI is one of the eight master’s degrees hosted at the School and was first introduced in 2016, jointly delivered with Makerere University College of Computing and Information Sciences (Mak-CoCIS). The two-year graduate training equips students with skills in health information systems design, data analytics, and digital health leadership through a hybrid model of face-to-face, online, and self-paced learning. So far, since its inception, nearly 50 graduates have completed the programme, many of whom have now gone on to lead national and regional health data initiatives. In August last month, the School received 26 new entrants for the MHI 2025/2026 cohort, reflecting its rising demand.

Now, the new project, launched on September 9, 2025, links TalTech’s MSc in Digital Health, one of Europe’s pioneering programmes introduced in 2009, with MakSPH’s Master of Health Informatics to strengthen curricula, mentor faculty, and give students exposure to global best practices. The goal is to create a skilled workforce capable of leading Uganda’s digital health transformation. The initiative is co-led by Prof. Peeter Ross, Professor of e-Health at TalTech, and Prof. Nazarius M. Tumwesigye, Professor of Epidemiology and Biostatistics at MakSPH. They are joined by Doris Kaljuste, Programme Director of the MSc in Digital Health, and Mr. Michael Anywar, Doctoral Student at TalTech and the initiator of the collaboration, as well as Ms. Irene Wanyana, MHI Programme Coordinator and PhD Candidate at Karolinska Institute, Sweden, and Mr. Chris A. Balwanaki, the Coordinator for the project at MakSPH.

At the centre, MakSPH Dean, Prof. Rhoda Wanyenze, receiving H.E. Girisch M. Nair, Honorary Consul of Estonia to Uganda, at the project launch. September 9, 2025. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH) and Estonia’s Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) kick-off meeting for two-year collaborative project to transform health informatics education and practice in Uganda, supported by the Estonian Centre for International Development (ESTDEV), 9th September 2025, MakSPH Auditorium, Kampala Uganda, East Africa.
At the centre, MakSPH Dean, Prof. Rhoda Wanyenze, receiving H.E. Girisch M. Nair, Honorary Consul of Estonia to Uganda, at the project launch. September 9, 2025.

Prof. Ross, a leading global authority on e-health and head of the Digital Health Research Unit at Tallinn University of Technology, commenting on the project and the link between health and technology, stressed that while health itself is not technology, the intelligent integration of digital tools is indispensable for making healthcare more efficient, affordable, and accessible. He underscored that this collaboration marks a key step in that direction, with capacity development and academic exchange key to sustainable digital transformation.

“Capacity building is critical. In Estonia, when the nationwide health information system was being launched, about a third of the budget went into training healthcare professionals. This required training trainers first, underscoring the strategic role of academia. Estonia has a master’s programme in digital health, while Makerere University offers a blended Master of Health Informatics. Together, these programmes can expand training across Uganda and beyond,” Prof. Ross explained, adding that the collaboration also gives Estonia the chance to test digital health solutions in a large, English-speaking population, while Uganda benefits from Estonia’s decades of experience and avoids common pitfalls.

Prof. Peeter Ross, Professor of e-Health at TalTech and Co-lead for the project, underscored that this collaboration marks a key step in the right direction, with capacity development and academic exchange key to sustainable digital transformation. September 9, 2025. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH) and Estonia’s Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) kick-off meeting for two-year collaborative project to transform health informatics education and practice in Uganda, supported by the Estonian Centre for International Development (ESTDEV), 9th September 2025, MakSPH Auditorium, Kampala Uganda, East Africa.
Prof. Peeter Ross, Professor of e-Health at TalTech and Co-lead for the project, underscored that this collaboration marks a key step in the right direction, with capacity development and academic exchange key to sustainable digital transformation. September 9, 2025.

Estonia, a Northern European country currently with about 1.37 million people and covering a total area of 45,339 km², is seen as one of Europe’s leaders in digital innovation. About 99 per cent of its public services are reportedly delivered online, and its health information system records nearly every citizen’s medical history from birth to death. The X-Road platform in the country enables secure, encrypted data exchange, while e-prescriptions cover almost all prescriptions nationwide. Meanwhile, the Digilugu.ee patient portal allows citizens to access their health records, track activity logs, and even generate certificates, a system widely trusted by users. The Estonian team revealed that the integrated digital health ecosystem shows how technology, governance, and policy work together to provide efficient, patient-centred care.

Conversely, Uganda’s growing digital ecosystem makes the timing of the collaboration strategic. The country currently has more than 43 million mobile subscriptions, over 26 million internet users, and more than 33 million mobile money accounts, creating fertile ground for scaling digital health solutions. With this, strengthening health informatics will build a skilled workforce needed to design, implement, and manage these solutions effectively.

The MakSPH Project Co-lead, Prof. Tumwesigye, hailed the partnership as a turning point for the MHI programme, noting that modules such as Health Analytics are being upgraded to give students hands-on experience in developing tools to digitise public and private health systems. He said Estonia’s model, where digital innovations are widely adopted and lead to measurable improvements, offers a blueprint Uganda can adapt to move beyond paper-based systems, improve data quality, and train graduates to design solutions that strengthen health outcomes.

MakSPH Project Co-lead, Prof. Nazarius M. Tumwesigye, speaking during the project launch. September 9, 2025. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH) and Estonia’s Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) kick-off meeting for two-year collaborative project to transform health informatics education and practice in Uganda, supported by the Estonian Centre for International Development (ESTDEV), 9th September 2025, MakSPH Auditorium, Kampala Uganda, East Africa.
MakSPH Project Co-lead, Prof. Nazarius M. Tumwesigye, speaking during the project launch. September 9, 2025.

“Uganda is still behind in digital health use. We rely heavily on paper-based systems, experience long delays in transmitting data from primary health facilities to the national level, and face issues with data quality, including missing or inaccurate figures. Strengthening our programme will help address these challenges and produce graduates who can design solutions that lead to better health outcomes. Learning from TalTech University and Estonia’s digital health success will help us put Uganda on a better footing for the future,” Prof. Tumwesigye observed, noting that Estonia’s model stands out for ensuring digital innovations are widely adopted and deliver measurable improvements in health system performance.

The Programme Coordinator, Ms. Irene Wanyana, noted that since its launch in 2016, the Health Informatics training at Makerere University has made a strong impact, earning a reputation as one of the leading graduate programmes of its kind in the region. She observed that faculty members and students have been instrumental in designing, developing, and supporting national health information systems critical to Uganda’s health sector. These include UgandaEMR, an advanced electronic medical record system now deployed in more than 1,700 health facilities; the Weekly Stock Status System, which enables real-time tracking of essential medical commodities; and the Early Infant Diagnosis Laboratory Information Management System (LIMS), which improves the management of HIV testing data for infants.

Still, the programme has contributed to the development of PrEP and DREAMS/OVC tracking systems, supporting HIV prevention and care for vulnerable populations such as adolescent girls, young women, and children. The graduate training has also strengthened national HIV surveillance through the Centralised Blood Screening (CBS) dashboard, advanced the Uganda Health Information Exchange Platform to improve interoperability, and facilitated the migration of critical health data systems into the Ministry of Health’s national data centres, continuing to ensure that health information is secure, reliable, and accessible nationwide.

MakSPH Health Informatics students at the 2024 Open Group India Awards in New Delhi, where they were recognised for Innovation & Excellence for their project on enterprise architecture. September, 2024. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH) and Estonia’s Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) kick-off meeting for two-year collaborative project to transform health informatics education and practice in Uganda, supported by the Estonian Centre for International Development (ESTDEV), 9th September 2025, MakSPH Auditorium, Kampala Uganda, East Africa.
MakSPH Health Informatics students at the 2024 Open Group India Awards in New Delhi, where they were recognised for Innovation & Excellence for their project on enterprise architecture. September, 2024.

Ms. Wanyana is optimistic that with the new collaboration with TalTech University in Estonia, MakSPH’s Health Informatics programme is poised to deliver even greater innovations and impact to transform Uganda’s digital health system. In September 2024, four of our MHI students, Mr. Edwin Ayebare, Mr. Brian Twesigye, Mr. Enock Mwesigwa, and Mr. Iving Mumbere, won a global Award of Distinction at the Open Group India Awards for Innovation & Excellence in New Delhi. Competing against 22 university teams worldwide, they were recognised for their innovative application of enterprise architecture to address real-world health system challenges, attesting to Makerere University’s global competitiveness.

Speaking at the launch event, H.E. Girisch M. Nair, Honorary Consul of Estonia to Uganda, emphasised that Estonia’s experience offers Uganda a practical blueprint for building interoperable systems, standardising health data, and strengthening national health information infrastructure. “This collaboration is a platform for us to aspire more. Imagine a patient in Bundibugyo with a secure digital ID linked to their electronic health record. Wherever they go, authorised health workers can access their records, prescriptions are issued electronically, and medicines are dispensed at registered pharmacies. This generates rich, actionable data that helps plan better, reduce waste, and improve health outcomes.”

H.E. Girisch M. Nair, Honorary Consul of Estonia to Uganda, speaking during the project launch. September 9, 2025. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH) and Estonia’s Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) kick-off meeting for two-year collaborative project to transform health informatics education and practice in Uganda, supported by the Estonian Centre for International Development (ESTDEV), 9th September 2025, MakSPH Auditorium, Kampala Uganda, East Africa.
H.E. Girisch M. Nair, Honorary Consul of Estonia to Uganda, speaking during the project launch. September 9, 2025.

There is evidence of the Estonian Consul’s remarks. A new study conducted in 2023 by a team from Makerere University School of Public Health, led by Assoc. Prof. Peter Waiswa, published this September in BMJ Global Health, confirmed that supporting Ugandan districts to adopt digital payments significantly improved the efficiency of mass vaccination campaigns in the country, reducing delays, cutting administrative bottlenecks, and enhancing transparency. The findings from this and similar multi-country studies by the same team show that with targeted support, cashless systems are both feasible and practical for strengthening public health.

For Mr. Jamiru Mpiima, an alumnus of MakSPH and graduate of the Health Informatics programme, these developments underscore the critical need for a skilled workforce to design, implement, and manage digital health systems effectively. Speaking on behalf of Mr. Paul Mbaka, Head of the Division of Health Information at Uganda’s Ministry of Health, Mr. Mpiima shared the Ministry’s progress in digitising health information systems, from electronic medical records to the electronic community health information system, and the lessons learned along the way. He urged stronger collaboration between MakSPH and the Ministry, particularly in training future health informatics professionals and building institutional capacity to manage change in Uganda’s digital health sector transformation.

During the launch, MakSPH Dean, Prof. Rhoda Wanyenze, commended the remarkable speed of the Estonia–Makerere collaboration, noting that within a year, early conversations had already matured into a funded joint project. She emphasised that this milestone marks not just the start of a promising partnership, but also a unique opportunity to embed it more firmly within Uganda’s health system. Prof. Wanyenze called on all partners, the Ministry of Health, Makerere University, and the Estonian counterparts, to pursue a strategic tripartite arrangement, stressing that such collaboration could greatly strengthen Uganda’s digital health systems, accelerate technological innovation, and deliver measurable improvements in national health outcomes.

MakSPH Dean, Prof. Rhoda Wanyenze, together with the project team. September, 2025. Makerere University School of Public Health (MakSPH) and Estonia’s Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) kick-off meeting for two-year collaborative project to transform health informatics education and practice in Uganda, supported by the Estonian Centre for International Development (ESTDEV), September 2025, MakSPH, Kampala Uganda, East Africa.
MakSPH Dean, Prof. Rhoda Wanyenze, together with the project team. September, 2025.

View on MakSPH

John Okeya

Continue Reading

Health

What works, what doesn’t work? Researchers uncover the effect of supporting districts to operationalise digital payments for vaccination campaign workers

Published

on

A nurse scrolls through her smartphone. Photo: DHPI-R, MakSPH, CHS, Makerere University, Kampala Uganda, East Africa.

By Joseph Odoi

A motivated and satisfied health workforce is critical for the success of mass vaccination campaigns against diseases like polio. High-quality vaccination campaigns can interrupt disease transmission, especially during and after periods of disrupted health services, such as those caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.

In sub-Saharan Africa, most vaccination campaign healthcare workers (VCHWs) have historically been paid in cash. Cash payments are often plagued by delays in funds disbursement, leakages, theft risks, and limited financial transparency. These challenges can negatively affect vaccination coverage and worker satisfaction.

To address these challenges, many countries are transitioning to digital payment systems, which are perceived as faster, more convenient, traceable, reliable, and easy to implement. Digital financial systems are already being rolled out in countries including Côte d’Ivoire, Ghana, Mali, Congo, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Uganda, with a projected population of nearly 41.6 million, had over 30 million registered mobile money customers using e-cash in 2019.

While early rollouts of digital payments have been largely successful, their full impact on vaccination campaign workers had not been systematically evaluated.

 From 2021 to 2024, Makerere University (Uganda) and the University of Dakar (Senegal), with support from the Gates Foundation and technical partners including the Solina Group, WHO AFRO, and the Ministries of Health and Finance in both embarked on an important journey of research  under the Digital Health Payment Initiatives and Research (DHPI-R) Project in  28 countries in Sub Saharan Africa

To explore the experiences and lessons of polio vaccination campaign healthcare workers (VCHWs), both male and female, during the 2022 oral poliovirus vaccination campaign in Uganda, researchers led by Prof. Peter Waiswa (principal investigator), together with Margaret McConnell, Juliet Aweko, Daniel Donald Mukuye, Charles Opio, Maggie Ssekitto Ashaba, Andrew Bakainaga, and Elizabeth Ekirapa-Kiracho, with support from the Gates Foundation, conducted a study titled “The Effect of Supporting Districts to Operationalise Digital Payments for Vaccination Campaign Workers: A Cluster Randomised Controlled Trial During the 2022 Polio Vaccination Campaign in Uganda.”

This study examined whether supporting districts to implement electronic cash (e-cash) payments, instead of cash, increased e-cash usage and improved vaccine campaign healthcare workers’ (VCHWs) motivation and satisfaction during an oral poliovirus vaccination campaign in 2022 in Uganda.

The  mixed method study  now  published in BMJ Global Health, September 2025  was conducted in 54 districts in Uganda that had set up the government e-cash payment platform by May 2022. It involved healthcare workers supporting the polio vaccination campaign, regardless of direct vaccine contact. This included nurses, clinicians (vaccinators), mobilisers, community health workers (village health team members), recorders, local council representatives, and supervisors. The unit of randomisation was the district, while the unit of enrolment and data collection was the individual worker.

Method and Setting

As part of this study , In November 2022, a total of 54 districts and 2,665 vaccination campaign healthcare workers (VCHWs) were enrolled in the study and randomly assigned to two groups. Intervention districts received training on using the government e-cash platform, including managing user roles, uploading beneficiary data, and generating payment reports.

The control districts received the standard support given to districts during mass vaccination campaigns from the MoH, MoFPED, WHO and other development partners. This support included group training on implementation of payments, provision of vaccination materials and financial aid.

The study collected data on how VCHWs were paid, their motivation, and their satisfaction with the payment method. Overall, 765 VCHWs in intervention districts and 589 in control districts received e-cash payments.

Findings

Mode of payment for the vaccination campaign healthcare workers

Overall, approximately half of the campaign workers, 50.8% (1354/2665) were paid digitally (e- cash), either using mobile money or via the bank (online supple mental table 2). Payment by e- cash was higher among females, 53.9% (656/1215) compared with males, 48.1% (698/1450) and was lowest among campaign workers aged 30–39 years, 48.7% (368/765). E- cash payment was higher in the intervention arm at 57.5% (765/1,330) in comparison to the control arm at 44.1% (589/1,335).

Satisfaction with payment received during the campaign

 Only 36.5% (705/1930) of the VCHWs were satisfied with the payment received during the campaign, with satisfaction being slightly higher in the intervention arm, 37.9% (353/931) compared with the control arm 35.2% (352/999) and among females 37.9% (351/925) compared with males 35.2% (354/1005). Satisfaction was lowest among the married workers, 35.7% (575/1611) compared with the other categories.

Timing and completeness of payments

Nearly, all VCHWs were paid after the campaign, 97.6% (1884/1930), with no significant difference between the intervention (98.1%, 913/931) and the control (97.2%, 971/999) arms

Delayed/non- payment was highest among those with no formal education, 34% (17/50) and among community mobilisers, 30.7% (392/1071). The majority (70.6%, 1362/1930) of the VCHWs stated that the payment received met or even exceeded their payment expectation.

Participants also stated that e-cash was convenient, transparent, time-saving, and cost-saving, as it reduced travel and waiting times and minimized informal deductions.

Despite these benefits and support to districts to operationalize digital payments , there was no significant difference in workers’ motivation or satisfaction between the intervention and control groups. The researchers attributed this  partly due to challenges associated with both cash and digital payment modes.

Challenges experienced in effecting payments at the district level

Also a number of challenges were uncovered in this study . Challenges with e-cash payments included unanticipated withdrawal charges, unreliable internet networks, and lengthy processes for validating mobile telephone numbers. For example, payments were delayed or not processed when VCHWs’ names did not match the registration details held by telecommunication companies, or when workers did not have phones registered in their names.

One key informant had this to say on challenges around e-cash payments

‘’ There was a general complaint of charges. Remember when they are dispersing funds, they stick to the budget exactly. They are not looking at the charges. And when you are also paying you have to allocate minus the charges. You get the point. So the people would be expecting let’s take an example of 150 000/= and then they get 149 something. So, they would ask, ‘Why are we getting less money?’ So we labored to explain to them that the bank is charging a certain fee to facilitate the e- cash. (KII_West_EPI FP) There were also challenges associated with an unreliable internet network that was necessary to facilitate log ins for approval of payments

On Challenges experienced in effecting payments at the district level ,Key informant interviews with district leaders involved in the payment process identified several bottlenecks  during the payment process of the campaign healthcare workers. One of the major e- cash payment challenges was a lengthy process of validating mobile telephone numbers. ensuring that the VCHW’s names matched the registered mobile account names attached to the telephone number provided by the VCHW for receipt of funds.

‘’Unsuccessful validation occurred when the VCHW’s names did not match the registration details held by the telecommunication companies. Payments for such individuals were delayed or not effected at all. Because some of them do not even have the phones, but they are very good at doing the work…Or if they have, then the phone is not registered in their names. We were supposed to bring that database of the community as well and feed them into the system. That became a problem’’. (KII_North_ADHO)

Suggestions to improve use of e-cash payment system

To increase the use of e- cash, the majority of key informants identified continued training of key staff as a critical intervention with subsequent follow- up to ensure payments are well implemented.

‘’We are not yet ready; our capacity hasn’t been built. We have a big knowledge gap regarding the e- cash system here in this district. (KII East CFO) We request for more training to be conversant [with the system], and to discuss the challenges together during that training, as we share the experiences. Where we have challenges, we sit together and see how they can be addressed’’.  (KII_Central_CFO)

The participants also expressed the need for feedback mechanisms to allow them to dialogue with the payers in case there was a delay in payment. Additionally, the participants also acknowledged that there was a need to gradually expand adoption of digital payments considering contextual barriers. A hybrid approach would be an alternative, especially in the remote and hard-to-reach districts.

Other suggested solutions include early preparation of campaign health worker databases to allow for the lengthy telephone validation processes, improvement of the internet infrastructure, consistent use of e- cash payments across programmes and inclusion of withdrawal charges when making payments.

Moving forward policy, the researchers recommend the need to support e- payment systems, in order to minimize challenges in the pay ment processes.

‘’Suggestions to improve the e- cash experience include training of personnel in charge of e- cash payments, timely creation of VCHWs databases, expanding e- cash payments across programmes for efficiency and inclusion of withdrawal charges for the digital payments. To ensure the institutionalisation of digital payment interventions across Uganda, several key enablers are essential. These include formal policy integration by the Ministry of Health and Ministry of Finance into operational guide lines and budget frameworks, as well as ongoing capacity strengthening at the district level to enhance digital planning, payroll management and troubleshooting. Reliable infrastructure such as mobile connectivity and access to digital financial services like mobile money must also be prioritised, especially in rural areas. Implementing routine monitoring and feedback systems will be vital for tracking payment timeliness, worker satisfaction and system performance, allowing for continuous improvement. Furthermore, fostering public–private partner ships with telecom providers and payment platforms is critical for cost- effective scaling. With strong political commitment, aligned funding and active community engagement, this model holds the potential for broader national and regional adoption, leading to more efficient and equitable health service delivery’’. The paper concludes on the way forward

To read the paper; click; https://gh.bmj.com/content/10/Suppl_4/e016666

About The DHPI-R project

The DHPI-R project was commissioned by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) to generate evidence on digital payments in Africa. Although inception, conceptualization of the proposal, and grant award were conducted earlier in 2021, the DHPIR project officially started implementing activities in November 2021, up to March 2025. DHPIR is hosted at the School of Public Health, College of Health Sciences at Makerere University and is implemented in Anglophone and Francophone hubs (countries) in Africa. The Anglophone hub is hosted at MAKSPH, while the Francophone Hub is hosted by the University of Dakar (UCAD) in Senegal.

DHP-IR was rooted in the End Polio Game Campaign, championed by WHO-Afro and partners in 28 countries in Sub Saharan Africa, where digital payments was a key strategy for timely and complete payments to campaign workers.

Mak Editor

Continue Reading

Trending